CMMC Certification Levels: A Complete Guide for DoD Contractors

CMMC Compliance for Small Businesses: What You Need to Know

If your small or mid-sized business works with the Department of Defense (DoD), compliance with the Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification (CMMC) is no longer optional—it’s a requirement. Any company handling Federal Contract Information (FCI) or Controlled Unclassified Information (CUI) must meet CMMC security standards or risk losing valuable government contracts.

For small and mid-sized businesses (SMBs), achieving compliance comes with a unique set of challenges. How much will it cost? How long will it take? Can you manage it in-house, or do you need a consultant?

This guide breaks down the key considerations, costs, timelines, and risks involved in CMMC compliance. Whether you’re preparing for self-assessment (DIY) or a third-party audit, this information will help you make informed decisions.

Understanding CMMC Levels and Their Impact on SMBs

CMMC 2.0 is designed to protect sensitive government data across the entire Defense Industrial Base (DIB). It consists of three levels, each with increasing security requirements:

Key Requirements of Level 1

Implements the15 basic security practices derived from FAR 52.204-21.

Focuses on basic cyber hygiene. While Level 1 does not require advanced cybersecurity measures, the DoD expects contractors to implement basic security best practices, including password security, access controls, and network security.
Requires an annual self-assessment (no third-party certification required). Unlike CMMC Level 2, which mandates third-party assessments, Level 1 companies can self-assess their compliance. However, this does not mean the process should be taken lightly.

Key Requirements of Level 2

Implements 110 security controls based on NIST SP 800-171 rev2.
Requires stronger cybersecurity protections, including:
- Multi-factor authentication (MFA) for all privileged accounts.
- End-to-end encryption of CUI.
- Strict access control measures (least privilege).
- Continuous system monitoring and incident response plans.
Some contractors may self-assess, while others must obtain third-party certification from a C3PAO (Cyber-AB Certified Third-Party Assessment Organization). To qualify for self-assessment, the organization must not work with CUI critical to national security.

Key Requirements of Level 3

Implements additional controls from NIST SP 800-172.
Requires enhanced security measures, such as:
- Zero-trust architecture.
- Real-time threat detection.
- Advanced penetration testing.
Third-party assessments conducted by the DoD’s Defense Industrial Base Cybersecurity Assessment Center (DIBCAC).

Important Note: The DoD is still refining Level 3 requirements, but companies should focus on achieving full Level 2 compliance first.

The CMMC 2.0 Timeline

2024: Final rule published indicating that SMBs should begin compliance efforts immediately.
2025: DoD starts including CMMC requirements in contracts.
2026-2028: Full rollout— A three-year phased rollout means more contracts will include CMMC requirements as time goes on.

Waiting until the last moment to get certified really isn’t an option as the entire process typically takes 9-12 months. In fact, according to a DIB Contractor Survey, 73% have spent more than 1 year preparing for CMMC and still aren’t done. Being proactive puts you ahead of the curve.

Determine Your Required CMMC Level

Business Size and Internal Capabilities

Do you have in-house IT/security staff with compliance experience?
Can your team handle ongoing cybersecurity management and audits?
How much time can your staff dedicate to compliance efforts?

Type of Data You Handle

Only FCI? A Level 1 self-assessment may be enough.
Handling CUI? You’ll need a Level 2 third-party assessment.

Contract Eligibility and Competitive Advantage

DoD is increasing enforcement of cybersecurity requirements.
Non-compliance means losing current and future contracts.
Early compliance can be a competitive advantage in securing DoD contracts.

Cost and Budget Considerations

DIY approaches may save upfront costs but can lead to costly mistakes.
Hiring a consultant requires a greater investment but reduces risk and speeds up certification.
Implementing security controls may require new tools, software, or system upgrades.

Risks of Non-Compliance for SMBs

Not all contracts require the same level of cybersecurity.

If your business fails to comply with CMMC, you could face:

Loss of DoD Contracts – Non-compliance means you can’t bid on new contracts.
Financial Penalties – Potential fines, contract loss, or legal repercussions for security failures.
Cybersecurity Breaches – Without proper security, your company is at higher risk of cyberattacks.
Reputational Damage – A failed assessment or security breach can hurt your business’ credibility.

DIY vs. Hiring a Consultant: Which is Right for You?

Factor	DIY (Self-Assessment)	Consultant-Assisted
Cost	Lower upfront cost	Higher initial investment, but cost-effective long term
Time	Takes longer	Faster due to expert guidance
Compliance Risk	Higher (risk of errors)	Lower (expert ensures compliance)
Best for	Level 1 businesses with strong IT teams	Level 2 businesses or those needing guidance

How SMBs Can Prepare for CMMC

Step 1: Determine Your CMMC Level

Do you only support FCI systems? → Level 1 (Self-assessment)
Do you process, store, or transmit CUI? → Level 2 required
Not sure? → Review client contracts or ask Contracting Officer (CO).

Step 2: Conduct a CMMC Gap Analysis

Identify missing security controls and create a remediation plan to fix weaknesses before an assessment.

A gap analysis identifies where your current cybersecurity posture falls short of CMMC requirements. This helps you proactively address deficiencies before an official assessment.

1. Evaluate Key Areas of Compliance:

- Access Controls – Are users and devices properly authenticated?
- Data Encryption – Is CUI encrypted at rest and in transit?
- Incident Response – Do you have a documented incident response plan?
- Logging & Monitoring – Are you tracking and reviewing logs for suspicious activity?
- Personnel Training – Are all employees trained in cyber hygiene and phishing awareness?

2. Test Your Existing Security Measures

- Conduct internal security audits and vulnerability scans.
- Review policies, procedures, and system configurations for compliance.
- Identify weak points that need remediation.

3. Document the Findings and Create an Action Plan

- Categorize gaps as high, medium, or low risk.
- Assign responsibilities and set deadlines for remediation.

Pro Tip: As a Cyber-AB Registered Practitioner Organization (RPO), Alluvionic’s CMMC gap analysis services provide defense contractors with a clear, actionable roadmap to CMMC Level 1 or Level 2 certification, ensuring you meet Department of Defense (DoD) cybersecurity requirements without unnecessary costs or delays.

Remediate CMMC Gaps

A CMMC gap analysis is like a cybersecurity health check—it identifies the vulnerabilities in your systems, policies, and processes. But just knowing the problems isn’t enough. Remediation is where the real work happens.

CMMC remediation is the process of:

Implementing missing cybersecurity controls (e.g., multi-factor authentication, secure backups, network monitoring).
Enhancing policies and procedures to align with NIST SP 800-171.
Deploying the right security tools to protect your systems from cyber threats.
Training your staff on cybersecurity best practices.
Documenting all security measures so you’re fully prepared for a CMMC assessment.

For companies with limited internal cybersecurity resources, remediation can feel like an insurmountable challenge. You have contracts to fulfill, projects to complete, and employees to manage—you can’t afford a security project that drags on for months and drains your budget. RPOs, like Alluvionic, can lead the remediation effort, ensuring compliance while minimizing disruption to your business.

Prepare for CMMC Assessments

Depending on your CMMC level, you’ll need to undergo self-assessments or third-party assessments to maintain compliance.

Assessment Types by Level:

Level 1:
- Annual self-assessment with results submitted to SPRS.
Level 2:
- Some contractors may self-assess, while others must obtain third-party certification from a C3PAO (Cyber-AB Certified Third-Party Assessment Organization). To qualify for self-assessment, the organization must not work with CUI critical to national security.
Level 3:
- Assessments are conducted by the Defense Industrial Base Cybersecurity Assessment Center (DIBCAC).
- It is estimated that only roughly 1% of contractors would require CMMC level 3.

How to Prepare:

Gather all required documentation (policies, procedures, system security plans).
Ensure security controls are properly implemented and tested.
Conduct mock assessments to identify any remaining gaps.

Pro Tip: Work with a Cyber-AB Registered Practitioner Organization (RPO) like Alluvionic to ensure readiness.

Ensure Your Subcontractors Are Compliant

CMMC requirements flow down to subcontractors—if your suppliers are non-compliant, you are non-compliant.

Steps to Ensure Compliance:

Vet subcontractors for CMMC readiness.
Require CMMC compliance in vendor contracts.
Help critical suppliers implement necessary security controls.
Regularly audit your supply chain for cybersecurity risks.

Pro Tip: Use CMMC compliance as a competitive advantage by ensuring your supply chain meets DoD requirements.

The Risks of Non-Compliance

Ignoring CMMC requirements comes with serious risks, including:
Ineligibility for DoD contracts – No certification, no contract.
Legal liability – If you falsely certify compliance, you could face heavy fines and legal action.
Loss of competitive advantage – Contractors who achieve CMMC compliance early will have a major edge in securing DoD contracts.

How Alluvionic Can Help You Achieve CMMC Certification

Achieving CMMC compliance can be complex—but you don’t have to go it alone. As a Cyber-AB Registered Practitioner Organization (RPO), Alluvionic specializes in helping defense contractors navigate the CMMC process efficiently.

Our CMMC Compliance Services

Scoping Your Environment – Determine what systems are processing, storing and transmitting Federal Contract Information and / or Controlled Unclassified Information Scoping

CMMC Readiness Assessments – Identify compliance gaps and create a remediation roadmap.
Policy & Documentation Development – Ensure your System Security Plan (SSP) and procedures meet CMMC standards.
Security Enhancements – Implement security controls required for CMMC Level 1, 2, or 3.
Subcontractor Compliance Support – Ensure your suppliers meet flow-down requirements.

Get CMMC-Ready Today

Contact

Read From Our Blog

Process Improvement

Are You Throwing Away Time and Money? 6 Hidden Inefficiencies Draining Your Business (and How to Fix Them)

Businesses love to talk about efficiency, but let’s be real—most are bleeding time and money in ways they don’t even notice. With the new administration

February 11, 2025

People in business attire talk while sitting around a glass table in desk chairs.

Project Managagement

Project Success: Growth Mindset Strategies for 2025

The start of a new year often inspires reflection and goal-setting. While individuals set resolutions to improve themselves, project teams and leaders can also embrace

January 2, 2025

Cartoon illustration of a toilet transformed into a grill and cooler combo, with a grill grate on the bowl and ice in the tank demonstrating the value of effective requirements gathering.

Project Managagement

How Thoughtful Requirements Gathering Prevents Project Misfires

Imagine you’ve been tasked as the project lead on an effort to conduct requirements gathering and ultimately create a new “Grill/Cooler Combo” product. You’ve done

December 4, 2024

Download Our Project Assurance^® Checklist

It’s simple. A project that gets off on the right foot is likely to take a successful journey. So why do so many projects fail? Use this checklist to assure your project succeeds from the beginning.

Whether you need project management, process improvement, cybersecurity, product development, training, or government services, Alluvionic has the expertise to provide Peace of Mind and Project Assurance^®.